Wolfy wakes each night with his brethren and together they select another player to eat by pointing at that player. You indicate the player you think they are pointing at, possibly using a laser pointer, and they give a thumbs up if you have the correct player. Their selection must be unanimous. If they do not make a unanimous selection, prompt them to do so. If they remain indecisive, you can chose to put them them back to sleep without their meal. You typically only need to do that once for the Werewolves to realize they need to quickly come to a consensus.